When considering a commercial or personal fence or gate replacement, it presents a prime opportunity for an upgrade. If your existing property fence is due for a renewal, you might find yourself deliberating between the merits of steel and wrought iron. Which one is the better choice for your business? Is the fence protecting your property in conjunction with an automated gate? While steel and wrought iron share certain characteristics, they also exhibit distinct differences. Understanding these nuances can be instrumental in making an informed decision about which material is the optimal fit for your business’s fencing needs. Here’s a comparison of the two to help you decide.
Steel is Less Expensive Than Iron
First, it’s important to understand the basic difference between steel and iron. Iron is a pure element, while steel is an alloy made by adding carbon to iron. This small addition significantly changes the properties of the material. One of the most notable advantages of steel over iron is cost. Steel is generally less expensive than iron, making it a more budget-friendly choice for projects that require large quantities of material or for structures that need to go higher. The inclusion of carbon in steel not only makes it more affordable but also easier to work with. Cutting steel into lengths is simpler and more cost-effective, adding further to its appeal from a financial perspective.
Steel is Easier to Work with Than Iron
When it comes to ease of handling, steel has a distinct advantage over iron due to its lighter weight. This difference is especially noticeable during the lifting and securing of the material in place. For example, installing a steel fence may require a smaller crew compared to the manpower needed for an iron fence. The carbon content in steel also contributes to its flexibility, allowing it to be shaped more easily. This is particularly beneficial for projects that aim for artistic and customized designs. Whether you’re looking to create intricate patterns or need specific shapes, steel offers greater versatility in crafting these effects.
Steel Can Last Longer but Can Break Very Suddenly
In terms of durability, steel generally outlasts iron. However, this longevity comes with its own set of considerations. One of the drawbacks of steel is that it tends to break suddenly upon impact, unlike iron, which shows signs of deterioration over time. This characteristic of steel can be undesirable in situations where the material will experience frequent use or stress. On the other hand, iron, particularly wrought iron, may require more frequent repairs, but these can be anticipated and managed due to the visible signs of wear and tear. Steel, while durable, may need complete replacement if it fails, whereas iron can often be repaired and maintained.
Choosing the Right Material for Your Project Depends on Budget and Location
Selecting the appropriate material for your project involves balancing cost, ease of installation, durability, and the specific needs of your application. If budget constraints are a major factor, and if the project requires extensive material that needs to be cut and shaped, steel is the preferable choice. Its ease of handling and flexibility in design also make it suitable for artistic and customized applications.
However, if the project involves heavy use or potential impacts, and the ability to see and manage wear is crucial, iron might be the better option despite its higher cost and weight. The need for regular maintenance with iron can be planned, preventing sudden failures that could occur with steel.
Match Your Fence and Gate’s Materials If You Can
When considering materials for your fence, it’s also important to ensure that your fence matches your gates. A cohesive look not only enhances the aesthetic appeal of your property but also adds to its overall value. Steel offers a versatile option for both fences and gates, allowing for a seamless design that can be customized to fit your specific preferences. The flexibility of steel in terms of shaping and design means you can achieve a uniform look across all barriers of your property.
Both Types Require Regular Maintenance
Welding steel is a straightforward process, largely due to the quick heating property of carbon. This makes steel an easier material to work with in terms of welding, as it heats up and bonds quickly, allowing for faster project completion. On the flip side, while welding iron may take a bit longer due to its different properties, iron welds tend to exhibit greater durability over time. This makes iron a reliable choice for projects where long-term strength and resilience are critical.
Rust is a significant concern for iron, which demands regular attention to prevent and manage corrosion. Steel, on the other hand, often incorporates chromium and nickel, which provide inherent rust resistance. This makes many steel products less prone to rust compared to iron. It’s important to note that not all steel fences are entirely rust-proof. Non-rust-proof steel fences can succumb to rust more rapidly than their iron counterparts. It’s worse if they are exposed to harsh environmental conditions without proper maintenance. Knowing the type of steel used in your fence is important for assessing its rust resistance.
Your Gates and Fences Need Regular Maintenance and Professional Servicing
Regardless of whether you choose steel or iron, a proactive maintenance plan is essential for preserving the longevity and aesthetic appeal of your fence. Regular inspections, cleaning, and protective treatments are necessary to prevent rust and other forms of deterioration. It’s advisable to consult with your professional installers to determine the best maintenance practices for your specific fence. If maintaining the fence seems overwhelming, consider hiring professionals to perform regular maintenance. This ensures that your fence remains in good condition without needing constant attention.
Both steel and iron are relatively easy to paint, allowing you to customize the appearance of your fence to match your property’s aesthetics. Painting not only enhances the visual appeal but also adds an extra layer of protection against the elements. When applying paint to steel or iron, it’s important to use a primer designed for metal surfaces and follow it up with a high-quality outdoor paint. This helps in creating a durable finish that can withstand weather conditions and prolong the life of the fence.
Iron Offers a Classic Look While Steel May be More Modern
Iron has a dignified look, giving the appearance of having been in place for a long time even when it’s new. Steel is shinier, and if you prefer a sleek, contemporary look, it’s probably the best option. Once you have an idea of what material type you want to use for your property, call a professional installer for a consultation. They’ll be able to quote you on installing a matching iron or steel gate for your property while they’re at it.